Charlotte sent copies of Shirley to selected leading authors of the day, including Elizabeth Gaskell. Gaskell and Charlotte subsequently met in August 1850 and began a friendship which, whilst not necessarily close, was significant in that Gaskell would write a biography of Charlotte after Charlotte's death in 1855. The biography, The Life of Charlotte Brontë, was published in 1857 and was unusual at the time in that, rather than analysing its subject's achievements, it instead concentrated on the private details of Charlotte's life, in particular placing emphasis on aspects which countered the accusations of 'coarseness' which had been levelled at Charlotte's writing. Though frank in places, Gaskell was selective about which details she revealed; for example, she suppressed details of Charlotte's love for Heger, a married man, as being too much of an affront to contemporary morals and as a possible source of distress to Charlotte's still-living friends, father and husband. Gaskell also provided doubtful and inaccurate information about Patrick Brontë, claiming, for example, that he did not allow his children to eat meat. This is refuted by one of Emily Brontë's diary papers, in which she describes the preparation of meat and potatoes for dinner at the parsonage, as Juliet Barker points out in her recent biography, The Brontës. It has been argued that the particular approach of The Life of Charlotte Brontë transferred the focus of attention away from the 'difficult' novels of not just Charlotte but all the Brontë sisters, and began a process of sanctification of their private lives. answers/charlotte-bronte
Then came in 1857 the Life of Charlotte Brontë, in two volumes. Miss Bronte, who had enjoyed the friendship of Mrs. Gaskell and had exchanged visits, died in March 1855. Two years earlier she had begged her publishers to postpone the issue of her own novel Villette in order that her friend's Ruth should not suffer. This biography, by its vivid presentation of the sad, melancholy and indeed tragic story of the three Brontë sisters, greatly widened the interest in their writings and gave its author a considerable place among English biographers. But much matter was contained in the first and second editions that was withdrawn from the third. Certain statements made by the writer as to the school of Charlotte Brontë's infancy, an identification of the "Lowood" of Jane Eyre with the existing school, and the acceptance of the story of Bramwell Brontë's ruin having been caused by the woman in whose house he had lived as tutor, brought threats of libel actions. Apologies were published, and the third edition of the book was modified, as Mrs. Gaskell declares, by "another hand." The book in any case remains one of the best biographies in the language nndb.com/people
Then came in 1857 the Life of Charlotte Brontë, in two volumes. Miss Bronte, who had enjoyed the friendship of Mrs. Gaskell and had exchanged visits, died in March 1855. Two years earlier she had begged her publishers to postpone the issue of her own novel Villette in order that her friend's Ruth should not suffer. This biography, by its vivid presentation of the sad, melancholy and indeed tragic story of the three Brontë sisters, greatly widened the interest in their writings and gave its author a considerable place among English biographers. But much matter was contained in the first and second editions that was withdrawn from the third. Certain statements made by the writer as to the school of Charlotte Brontë's infancy, an identification of the "Lowood" of Jane Eyre with the existing school, and the acceptance of the story of Bramwell Brontë's ruin having been caused by the woman in whose house he had lived as tutor, brought threats of libel actions. Apologies were published, and the third edition of the book was modified, as Mrs. Gaskell declares, by "another hand." The book in any case remains one of the best biographies in the language nndb.com/people
Hello Geri...I so love Mrs. Gaskell's writings about Charlotte and the family, I think because mostly, she knew her, and you can read her heart in the book, she cared about Charlotte so much, and it shows.
BeantwoordenVerwijderenI've just seen on DVD Elizabeth's North & South, and Cranford...they were fantastic! Have you seen them? I haven't read the books but I just ordered them...can't wait to read the stories in her own words.
Happy Spring to you...
xo Jessica
Hi Jessica,
BeantwoordenVerwijderenI own the DVD Cranford. I never read the book. And never I read or saw North and South. It can be a good idea to have it from the library.
I love ""the life of Charlotte Bronte"". Indeed, because Elisabeth Gaskell was so close to Charlotte. It also is interesting to compare her biography with, for instance, the own Juliet Barker made. It is interesting to know what problems E. Gaskell had to face while writing her biography. And how shocked she must have been founding out about Charlotte's love for Constantin Heger.
Geri, you will love North & South, I hope you can find it! You know, I really never thought about how Elizabeth would have felt finding out about Charlotte & M. Heger...to bad this wasn't discovered in some sort of diary or letter.
BeantwoordenVerwijderenI've ordered Juliet Barker's and Lucasta Miller's books about the Bronte's...they should be here any day and I can't wait to read them. Other that Mrs. Gaskell's biography, I've only read Rebecca Fraser's book, which I loved...it will be wonderful to read the other ladies persectives on our favorite family.
xo J~
I don't know the biography of Lucasta Miller. I like to have this as well. Good idea. The other books I have allready. I love them both. I wish you a lot of reading pleasure.
BeantwoordenVerwijderenMaybe there is a diary or letter from Elisabeth Gaskell about this subject? I will search for it. Maybe someone who read this can help?